Posted: November 14, 2024
On Thursday, the Death Penalty Information Center (“DPI”) released a new report detailing the troubling racial history of the federal death penalty. Fool’s Gold: How the Federal Death Penalty Has Perpetuated Racially Discriminatory Practices Throughout History documents how racial discrimination has been a throughline in the application of the federal death penalty since the 1800s. The report explains that, despite often being mischaracterized as the “gold standard” of the death penalty, the same systemic problems of racial bias, ineffective counsel, and arbitrariness that exist in state level death penalty systems are also found in the federal death penalty system.
DPI’s review of modern statistics reveals the continuing legacy of racial disparities in federal death prosecutions and sentencing. 73% of all cases selected for death penalty prosecution between 1989 and June 2024 have been authorized for non-white defendants. Furthermore, a study of these modern statistics found a correlation between cases with white female victims and the likelihood of a defendant receiving a death sentence. This is consistent with many state-level reports detailing the profound effect of the race of victim bias, which is one of the most persistent forms of racial bias found in the death penalty.
