Hong Kong .. and why did Neville Sarony SC not get Lam’s approval ? This probably didn’t help….”It really is time for the adults to impose some basic common sense in the kindergarten that poses for a government”

Doug Clark published to China Lis Law over the weekend

Neville Sarony SC is eminently qualified to serve on the JOC, having practiced at the bar in HK for many years.
He has an interesting background.  He served in the Gurkha Rifles in Malaya and has written a number of books.
Here is a profile:
Here are a collection of Neville Sarony’s writings from EJ Insight.

As you will see he has strong opinions on the justice system, including these comments on the workings of then system in NSL cases:

From “Tinkering with Justice”:

“Those charged with offences under the National Security Law fall prey to a dystopian procedure that owes almost nothing to the due process which the liberal rule of law accords.

The right to be granted bail pending trial and to be judged by a jury of one’s fellow citizens have no place in this authoritarian pedagogy, indeed it reverses the fundamental precept that no-one is guilty until that has been proved.

Nevertheless, despite the notoriety attaching to the plastic gamut of offences under the NSL, they constitute a very slim slice of the justice system, the vast majority of which is unchanged.

In effect, NSL cases are confined within a criminal law vacuum.”

His article on “Covidiocy”  which begins: “It really is time for the adults to impose some basic common sense in the kindergarten that poses for a government” offers some insight to why the CE may have decided he is not her preferred candidate.